| Year | Moment | Sport: |
| | |
| | |
| 1951 | Kentucky football upsets Oklahoma in Sugar Bowl ending their 31 game winning streak | CF |
| 1952 | United States wins Summer Olympic medal count over the Soviet Union | Olympics |
| 1953 | Wake basketball wins first-ever conference tourney as member of the SoCon | CB |
| 1954 | Milan High School wins Indiana State High School Basketball Championship | HS Bball |
| 1955 | Wake Forest baseball wins College Baseball World Series | CBB |
| 1956 | San Francisco Dons win mid-major national basketball title with perfect 29-0 record | CB |
| 1957 | Wilmington’s Althea Gibson becomes first black player to win Wimbledon | Tennis |
| 1958 | Kentucky Wildcats win national basketball championship over Seattle | CB |
| 1959 | California wins epic one point NCAA Bball title game over West Virginia | CB |
| 1960 | Bill Mazeroski walk off World Series home run | MLB |
| 1961 | Wake Forest wins first ACC basketball Tournament title | CB |
| 1962 | Wake Forest basketball makes only Final Four appearance and wins third place game | CB |
| 1963 | Loyola Chicago basketball wins national basketball championship | CB |
| 1964 | Muhammad Ali (then Cassius Clay) wins heavyweight title over Sonny Liston | Boxing |
| 1965 | Jack Nicklaus breaks Masters scoring record en route to title | Golf |
| 1966 | England wins first and only World Cup Soccer Championship | Soccer |
| 1967 | Jack Nicklaus breaks US Open socring record en route to title | Golf |
| 1968 | Bob Beamon 29 foot gold medal long jump | Olympics |
| 1969 | Joe Namath guarantees Super Bowl Upset | NFL |
| 1970 | Willis Reed Inspires NY Knicks to NBA Title | NBA |
| 1971 | Western Kentucky makes Cinderella Run to NCAA Tournament Final Four | CB |
| 1972 | American Mark Spitz wins record seven Olympic gold medals | Olympics |
| 1973 | Secretariat wins Triple Crown by 31 lengths | Horse |
| 1974 | Muhammad Ali upsets Foreman in Rumble in the Jungle | Boxing |
| 1975 | Muhammad Ali beats Joe Frazier in Thrilla in Manilla | Boxing |
| 1976 | Kentucky football wins share of SEC title for first time in 26 years | CF |
| 1977 | Seattle Slew wins horse racing triple crown | Horse |
| 1978 | Kentucky basketball wins national title over Duke | CB |
| 1979 | Wake Forest football stuns # 12 Georgia on the road | CF |
| 1980 | Miracle On Ice | Olympics |
| 1981 | Larry Bird wins first NBA title with the Boston Celtics | NBA |
| 1982 | “The Play” Cal-Stanford | CF |
| 1983 | NC State “Cardiac Pack” win national title | CB |
| 1984 | BYU wins Holiday to become last consensus national champ outside of the Power 5 | CF |
| 1985 | Villanova Cinderella Championship | CB |
| 1986 | Jack Nicklaus wins Masters | Golf |
| 1987 | Minnesota Twins win World Series in 7 games | MLB |
| 1988 | Kirk Gibson World Series Home Run | MLB |
| 1989 | Michael Chang becomes youngest man to win Grand Slam with French Open title | Tennis |
| 1990 | Loyola Marymount makes Cinderella run to Elite 8 in honor of Hank Gathers | CB |
| 1991 | Michael Jordan wins first NBA Championship with Chicago Bulls | NBA |
| 1992 | Andre Agassi wins first grand slam and only Wimbledon title of his career | Tennis |
| 1993 | Boston College stuns Notre Dame in epic college football upset | CF |
| 1994 | George Foreman becaomes oldest heavyweight champ | Boxing |
| 1995 | Northwestern football wins Cinderella Big Ten Title | CF |
| 1996 | Kentucky basketball wins first national title of my lifetime | CB |
| 1997 | Michael Jordan Flu Game captapults Bulls to 5th NBA Title | NBA |
| 1998 | Kentucky basketball wins national title with three straight comeback wins | CB |
| 1999 | Andre Agassi wins French Open to complete career grand slam | Tennis |
| 2000 | South Carolina football shocks world with upset of # 10 Georgia | CF |
| 2001 | 15-seeded Hampton beats Iowa State in first round of NCAA Tournament | CB |
| 2002 | Patriots upset Rams in Super Bowl | NFL |
| 2003 | Ohio State shocks Miami in 2OT to win BCS Title Game | CF |
| 2004 | Boston Red Sox end Curse of the Bambino | MLB |
| 2005 | # 4 Wake Forest basketball beats # 3 North Carolina in regular season thriller | CB |
| 2006 | Wake Forest football wins ACC Championship | CF |
| 2007 | Boise State beats Oklahoma in Fiesta Bowl | CF |
| 2008 | Kansas beats Memphis in NCAA Title Game with buzzer beater | CB |
| 2009 | Alabama wins SEC Football Championship | CF |
| 2010 | South Carolina baseball wins first NCAA baseball championship | CBB |
| 2011 | Kentucky football ends epic drought against Tennessee | CF |
| 2012 | Andy Murray wins Olympic Gold | Olympics |
| 2013 | Andy Murray ends great British drought at Wimbledon | Tennis |
| 2014 | Florida State’s final drive ends SEC reign of terror | CF |
| 2015 | American Pharoah wins Horse Racing Triple Crown | Horse |
| 2016 | Andy Murray wins 2nd Wimbledon title on weekend of Andrew’s birth | Tennis |
| 2017 | New England Patriots complete greatest comeback in SB history over Falcons | NFL |
| 2018 | UMBC pulls off first 16 over 1 upset in NCAA Tournament | CB |
| 2019 | Expos/Nationals franchise wins first world series | MLB |
| 2020 | Dominic Thiem wins first grand slam title in fifth set tiebreaker | Tennis |
| 2021 | Wake Forest football wins the ACC Atlantic title | CF |
| 2022 | St. Peter’s Peacocks make greatest Elite 8 Cinderella run ever as 15 seed | CB |
| 2023 | Fairleigh Dickinson pulls off biggest First Round Upset Ever | CB |
| 2024 | South Carolina women win national basketball title with undefeated season | CB |
| 2025 | UNCW wins CAA tourney title and returns to the Big Dance for the first time in 8 years | CB |