| Year | Moment | Sport: |
| | |
| | |
| 1951 | Montreal Canadiens lose Stanley Cup Finals 4 games to 1 to rival Toronoto Maple Leafs | NHL |
| 1952 | Kentucky basketball is upset in 2nd round of NCAA tourney to St. John’s | CB |
| 1953 | U.S. tennis loves Davis Cup finals to Australia in 3-2 heartbreaker | Tennis |
| 1954 | Minneapolis Lakers beat Syracuse Nationals in Game 7 of NBA Finals to pull off first three-peat | Pro Bball |
| 1955 | Kentucky basketball gets upset by Marquette in 2nd round of NCAA tourney | CB |
| 1956 | Oregon State football chokes away upset bid of Iowa | CF |
| 1957 | Auburn wins first of two corrupt national football titles | CF |
| 1958 | Tim Tam injures foot in stretch run and loses Triple Crown bid with 2nd place finish in the Belmont | Horse |
| 1959 | Louisville blows out favored Kentucky in NCAA Tournament Sweet 16 | CB |
| 1960 | Ohio State wins national basketball championship | CB |
| 1961 | Cincinnati Reds lose World Series to New York Yankees | MLB |
| 1962 | Ohio State beats Wake Forest in Final Four game | CB |
| 1963 | Boston Patriots get destroyed in AFL Championship game by San Diego Chargers | Pro Fball |
| 1964 | Northern Dancer loses Triple Crown bid with third place finish in Belmont | Horse |
| 1965 | UCLA wins second national title with in over Michigan | CB |
| 1966 | Texas Western upsets Kentucky in National Title Game | CB |
| 1967 | UCLA begins basketball reign of terror with first of seven straight national titles | CB |
| 1968 | Ohio State beats Kentucky in Elite 8 with bank shot in the final seconds | CB |
| 1969 | Drake falls just short of monumental upset over UCLA in Final Four | CB |
| 1970 | Artis Gilmore leads Jacksonville to shocking Elite 8 upset over Kentucky | CB |
| 1971 | Muhammad Ali suffers first career loss to Joe Frazier | Boxing |
| 1972 | Soviet Union screws U.S. in bball gold medal game | Olympic |
| 1973 | Kentucky Colonels lose ABA Finals in seven game series | Pro Bball |
| 1974 | Notre Dame beats Alabama in college football national title game | CF |
| 1975 | UCLA beats Kentucky in NCAA Basketball Title Game | CB |
| 1976 | Pittsburgh Steelers beat Dallas Cowboys in Super Bowl X | Pro Fball |
| 1977 | UNC-Charlotte’s Cinderella run comes to hearbreaking end in Final Four | CB |
| 1978 | Affirmed Beats Alydar to win last Triple Crown | Horse |
| 1979 | Michigan State beats Indiana State in NCAA Title Game | CB |
| 1980 | Kentucky loses another NCAA tourney heartbreaker to Duke | CB |
| 1981 | Pleasant Colony squanders Triple Crown chance in Belmont | Horse |
| 1982 | Clemson football wins national championship | CF |
| 1983 | Wake Forest bball loses heartbreaker to NC State in first round of ACC tourney | CB |
| 1984 | Kentucky basketball plays worst 2nd half ever in loss to Georgetown | CB |
| 1985 | LA Lakers defeat Boston Celtics in NBA Finals | Pro Bball |
| 1986 | New England Patriots get destroyed in first Super Bowl appearance | Pro Fball |
| 1987 | LA Lakers beat Boston Celtics in last Magic vs. Bird NBA Finals | Pro Bball |
| 1988 | Roy Jones Jr. gets screwed out of Olympic Gold Medal | Olympic |
| 1989 | Detroit Piston beat Chicago Bulls in Eastern Conference Finals | Pro Bball |
| 1990 | Detroit Pistons beat Chicago Bulls in Game 7 of the Eastern Conference Finals | Pro Bball |
| 1991 | Giants beat Bills in closest Super Bowl ever | Pro Fball |
| 1992 | Christian Laettner Shot beats Kentucky in Elite Eight | CB |
| 1993 | Kentcuky football loses Peach Bowl heartbreaker to Clemson | CF |
| 1994 | Kentucky basketball gets upset by Marquette in 2nd Round of NCAA tourney | CB |
| 1995 | Syracuse basketball chokes away 2nd Round NCAA tourney game to Arkansas | CB |
| 1996 | Greg Norman chokes away best chance at major on U.S. soil at Masters | Golf |
| 1997 | Refs screw Arizona State out of Rose Bowl and National Title | CF |
| 1998 | Real Quiet loses Triple Crown in photo finish | Horse |
| 1999 | Tennessee football beats Florida State in first-ever BCS Title Game | CF |
| 2000 | Clemson football beats South Carolina with controversial catch | CF |
| 2001 | Tim Henman loses Wimbledon semifinal to Goran Ivanisevic | Tennis |
| 2002 | LSU football beats Kentucky with “Bluegrass Miracle” Hail Mary | CF |
| 2003 | Cubs and Red Sox blow championship series in consecutive days | MLB |
| 2004 | Smarty Jones loses Triple Crown | Horse |
| 2005 | West Virginia beats Wake Forest in 2nd Round of NCAA Tournament | CB |
| 2006 | Gonzaga chokes away Sweet 16 game against UCLA | CB |
| 2007 | Wake Forest fooball loses Orange Bowl game against Louisville | CF |
| 2008 | Undefeated New England Patriots lose to NY Giants in Super Bowl | Pro Fball |
| 2009 | Tom Watson loses British Open heartbreaker | Golf |
| 2010 | Black Friday of College Football: Cam Newton comeback and Boise FG choke | CF |
| 2011 | UConn beats Butler in NCAA Basketball Title Game | CB |
| 2012 | NY Giants beat New England Patriots in Super Bowl for second-time in 5 years | Pro Fball |
| 2013 | South Carolina football loses to Georgia in SEC opener | CF |
| 2014 | California Chrome loses Belmont Stakes | Horse |
| 2015 | Wisconsin beats undefeated Kentucky in Final Four | CF |
| 2016 | Carolina Panthers lose Super Bowl 50 | Pro Fball |
| 2017 | North Carolina Bball wins NCAA Basketball title game | CB |
| 2018 | Philadelphia Eagles beat New England Patriots in Super Bowl LII | Pro Fball |
| 2019 | Maximum Security gets screwed out of Kentucky Derby | Horse |
| 2020 | March Madness gets canceled | CB |
| 2021 | Wake Forest loses ACC Football Championship Game to Pitt | CF |
| 2022 | Mike Leach dies | CF |
| 2023 | LSU beats Wake Forest with extra inning walk off HR in College World Series semifinal | NCAA Baseball |
| 2024 | Black Christmas: Kentucky and SC both get upset in first round of NCAA tourney | CB |
| 2025 | November Nightmare: Toronoto Blue Jays choke away Game 7 of World Series to LA Dodgers | MLB |