Per Wikipedia, a sports Cinderella refers to a situation in which a competitor or team achieves far greater success than would reasonably have been best expected. No place in sports embodies and embraces this Cinderella concept more than the NCAA men’s basketball tournament where we see small schools, underdogs, and afterthoughts pull off March Madness upsets on an annual basis. Three years ago I wrote a detailed analysis about the greatest Cinderella to make it to each round of the tournament. I am now going do to a spin-off piece on that prior essay and detail my analysis on the greatest Cinderellas on each NCAA tournament seed line. Please note that teams seeded 1-4 can’t be considered “Cinderellas” in my opinion and are thus excluded from this article. We will therefore be focusing our analysis on teams seeded 5-16.  Also notice that this article is entitled “greatest cinderella by seed” not “greatest team by seed”.  Thus, I am not deciding which team at each seed line was the overall  strongest, just which team at each seed line made the most improbable run in the tournament.  You will also not see any traditional blue bloods featured in this article.  I strongly believe that no matter what seed number is next to their name, traditional powerhouses such as Kentucky, North Carolina, and UCLA can’t be Cinderellas (though you will see Kansas does slip in here).  A Cinderella must be a team that emerges out of nowhere to achieve success few thought possible.  Therefore, you will not see Kentucky’s run to the title game as an 8 seed in 2014 on this list; nor will you see UCLA’s run to the 2021 Final Four as an 11 seed or 8th seeded North Carolina’s run to the 2000 Final Four.  Without further ado, let’s break down the greatest Cinderellas of all time at each spot in the bracket.  

Greatest 16th Seeded Cinderella: Fairleigh Dickinson, 2023- Many people say that in order to truly become a Cinderella you have to pull off multiple upsets, not just win a single game. Using this logic, the FDU squad from 2023 is the only 16 seed that meets this criteria as they pulled off an upset over Texas Southern in the First Four and then stunned Purdue in the First Round two days later. And even though UMBC was the first team to pull off the 16 over 1 feat, FDU’s upset was definitively more impressive when you consider Purdue wasn’t missing a star player like Virginia in 2018 was, FDU had a NET ranking of 300 vs.UMBC”s ranking of 131, and FDU was mathematically the shortest team in the country that was matched up against basketball’s tallest superstar in Zach Edey. Yeah, this was definitely an upset for the ages.

—————————————————————————————————————-

Greatest 15th Seeded Cinderella: Saint Peter’s 2022- Believe it or not, twice as many 15 seeds (4) have made it to the Sweet 16 as 14 seeds (2) since the tournament expanded to 64 teams in 1985. And only one team seeded 13 or lower has ever made it the Elite Eight and that was the incredible 2023 Peacock squad. This feat is even more impressive when you consider they had beat perennial powerhouses Kentucky and Purdue to get there.

—————————————————————————————————————

Greatest 14th Seeded Cinderella: Chattanooga, 1997- It can certainly be argued that the 14 seeds in the NCAA tournament have performed, relative to their expectations, worse than any other. As stated above, four 15 seeds have made it to the Sweet 16 and one has made it to the Elite 8, but only two 14 seeds have made it to the Sweet 16: Cleveland State in 1986 and Chattanooga in 1997 and none have gone beyond that. You could certainly make a case for either Cleveland State or Chattanooga to take this spot, but I am going to go with the Mocs due to the fact that their ’97 tourney run was the first great NCAA tourney Cinderella run I can vividly remember from my childhood. In fact, I have a funny anecdote about that team. Growing up in Lexington, Kentucky, it was considered a major faux pas to wear any other college team gear to school besides Kentucky Wildcat shirts and hats. Nevertheless, I had a friend in 5th grade (let’s call him Noah) who had an aunt that attended the University of Tennessee-Chattanooga. She had thus given him a hideous UT-Chattanooga sweatshirt that looked like something that dated back to the 70’s, and for whatever reason, he wore it frequently to school. As a result, Noah would frequently get teased for wearing an ugly sweatshirt from an obscure out-of-state school. However, I vividly remember Noah wearing his UT-Chattanooga sweatshirt on the Monday after the Mocs made it to the Sweet 16 in March of 1997. And for that one day… no one made fun of that sweatshirt. In fact, for that one day, that was the coolest shirt in school. That’s the power of March Madness… it can turn a hideous and obscure sweatshirt into the most fashionable clothing item in fifth grade.

—————————————————————————————————————

Greatest 13th Seeded Cinderella: Valparaiso, 1998-  This was a tough call to make because six different 13 seeds have made it to the Sweet 16 over the years but not a single one has made it to the Elite 8. The 2012 Ohio Bobcats were the 13 seed who came closest to winning their Sweet 16 game as they took the # 1 seeded North Carolina Tar Heels to overtime. In fact, I vividly remember Clark Kellogg anxiously watching his son, who was a guard for the Bobcats at the time, play that overtime period while he sat at the booth of a different NCAA tourney site calling a different NCAA tournament game. However, I am going with a different father-son duo for this spot and anointing Valpo’s Bryce and Homer Drew as the greatest 13 seeded Cinderella of all-time.  That is because  Bryce Drew, coached by his father Homer, hit maybe the greatest buzzer beater in the history of the first round with his running three pointer at the buzzer to beat Ole Miss in 1998.  The Crusaders then followed that up with an overtime victory over 12th seeded Florida State to reach the sweet 16 for the only time in school history.

—————————————————————————————————————

Greatest 12th Seeded Cinderella: Oregon State, 2021- Two 12 seeds have made it to the Elite 8 and neither one is a traditional mid-major Cinderella.  Missouri first achieved the feat in 2002 with Quinn Snyder at helm and the Beavers followed suit 19 years later by winning three games in the “Covid protocol” tournament of 2021.  Both of these tourney runs were assisted by upsets in their respective brackets, as neither of these 12 seeds had to face a 1 seed in the Sweet 16.  In fact, to this day, no team seeded lower than an 11 has ever beaten a # 1 1 seed in the NCAA tournament.  The key difference between Oregon State in 2021 and Missouri in 2002 though, is that the Beavers had to win their conference tourney just to make it to the dance in the first place; while, the Tigers had earned an at-large bid in ‘02.  Also, Oregon State was predicted to finish dead last in the preseason Pac-12 media poll in 2021, whereas, Missouri had won an NCAA tourney game in the year prior.  

—————————————————————————————————————

Greatest 11th Seeded Cinderella: Loyola-Chicago, 2018-  Five different 11 seeds have made it to the Final Four, but only one of these five was a mid-major that got there without receiving an at-large bid. In fact, the Ramblers would not likely have been invited to the 2018 dance had they not won the Missouri Valley Tournament that season. Once they earned their bid though, Porter Moser’s squad went on a magical run alongside a 97 year old nun named Sister Jean (pictured below).

—————————————————————————————————————

Greatest 10th Seeded Cinderella: Syracuse, 2016-  Oddly enough, five different 11 seeds have made it to the Final Four but only one 10 seed has gotten there.  As a result, the 2016 Syracuse Orange win this category by default.  I actually attended the Orange’s final four game in Houston that season (see photo below).  

—————————————————————————————————————

Greatest 9th Seeded Cinderella: Florida Atlantic, 2023-  While we typically associate 9 seeds with middling major conference teams, the only two 9 seeds to reach the Final Four were actually mid-major Cinderellas that should have both advanced to the national title game.  The first of these squads was Wichita State in 2013, who at the time was a member of the Missouri Valley Conference.  This squad, which featured future NBA players, Fred Van Vleet, Cleanthony Early, and Ron Baker, led for the majority of the game against a heavily favored Louisville squad in a game I also attended in-person in Atlanta.  Then a decade later, the 9th seeded FAU Owls, coached by Dusty May, had San Diego State beaten in their national semifinal matchup, only to have their hearts ripped out of their chests with a Lamont Butler buzzer beater. Because the FAU program had less name recognition, slightly less talent, played in a lesser conference, and came closer to winning their Final Four game than Wichita, I am giving the Owls the nod over the Shockers here.  

—————————————————————————————————————

Greatest 8th Seeded Cinderella: Villanova, 1985-  There’s no debate here, as the ‘85 Villanova squad still holds the distinction as the lowest seeded team ever to win the national championship.  In all, Three three number eight seeds have made it to the national title game, but only one was able to seal the deal and win it all. The Wildcats did it by playing a near perfect game (78.6% field goal percentage) in an upset win over heavily favored Georgetown. Not to mention this amazing event happened just a few miles from my house in Lexington, Kentucky, while I was in utero, just a few months before birth. And you wonder why I was born obsessed with this tournament?

—————————————————————————————————————

Greatest 7th Seeded Cinderella: South Carolina, 2017-  This selection is somewhat controversial in that we actually had a 7 seed win the tournament when UConn accomplished this feat with Shabazz Napier leading the way in 2014.  However, that was the Huskies’ fourth national championship, and I just can’t call a program with that much prominence and a team with that much talent a “Cinderella”.  In all, three 7 seeds have made it to the Final Four, the aforementioned UConn squad, Michigan State in 2015, and South Carolina in 2017, and the Gamecocks are the only true Cinderella in this bunch.  Yes, I understand that South Carolina is an SEC school with a sizable athletic budget and fan base, but keep in mind that prior to this tourney, the Gamecocks had not won a single NCAA tournament game since 1973!  To make matters worse, they have not won another NCAA tournament game since their magical 2017 run, so their four wins in that one tournament are the only tourney wins for this school in the past 53 seasons! Their work in 2017 is even more impressive and improbable when you consider that all four of their tourney wins came against power conference programs that have national title banners hanging in their respective arenas (Marquette, Duke, Baylor, and Florida).

—————————————————————————————————————

Greatest 6th Seeded Cinderella: Kansas, 1988- A lot of NC State fans aren’t going to like the fact the ‘83 NC State team isn’t selected for this spot, but the rest of the teams are on this list are from the 64-68 team era (post 1984), so I am going to stick with that principle and go with the only 6 seed to win a national title since 1985.  Danny (Manning) and Miracles shocked the college basketball world in ‘88 by beating two of their higher seeded arch rivals, Kansas State and Oklahoma, as well as the up and coming Duke Blue Devils in the final 3 rounds of the tournament to claim this national championship.  This feat is particularly impressive when you consider that the Jayhawks lost at home earlier that season to both Oklahoma and K-State by a combined 19 points.       

—————————————————————————————————————

Greatest 5th Seeded Cinderella: Butler, 2010- One of the greatest statistical anomalies in March Madness is that every seed numbered 1-8 has won a national title except for a # 5 seed.  Four different five seeds have made it to the title game (San Diego State in 2023, Butler in 2010, Indiana in 2002, and Florida in 2000) and the only that fits the bill as a true Cinderella is Butler.  The Bulldogs were still in a mid-major league at the time (the Horizon) and they had never made it to the Elite 8, much less the Final Four, prior to 2010.  Nevertheless, future NBA star Gordon Hayward carried this team to the 2010 NCAA title game with upset victories over Syracuse, Kansas State, and Michigan State before the Bulldogs came within inches of stunning the Duke Blue Devils in the national title game.   Hayward’s final halfcourt heave that just missed (see photo below) will go down in sports history alongside Tom Watson’s miraculous 2009 British OPen run as one of the all-time “close but no cigar” moments in sports history.  One of my favorite factual tidbits about this squad is that because the Final Four and National Championship Game were held in their hometown of Indianapolis, the players actually attended class on the day of the national title game.  In today’s age, of semi-professional college basketball that would be unheard of.